Italy’s Constitutional Court has done it again: moved rainbow families one step forward, then pointed firmly at Parliament for the rest.

In two linked rulings filed on Thursday, November 12, the court struck down the rule that only married couples can jointly adopt an adult, a win for couples in civil unions. But on the bigger question, whether civil-union couples can adopt children from abroad, it declined to act and said the decision belongs to lawmakers.

The short version

  • Ruling 195/2026: Couples in a civil union can now jointly adopt the same adult. The old rule reserved that for married couples.
  • Ruling 194/2026: Civil-union couples still can’t apply for international adoption of a child. The court said the law needs updating, but that’s Parliament’s job.
  • When: The adult-adoption change kicks in the day after the ruling appears in the official Gazzetta Ufficiale.
  • Why it matters: In Italy, same-sex couples can’t marry. Civil unions, created in 2016, are their only option, so any rule written for “husband and wife” shuts them out.

The case that started it

It began in Milan. Two people who entered a civil union there on November 11, 2016 asked the city’s court to jointly adopt an adult relative of one of them, someone they had been close to since birth, according to the Constitutional Court’s case file. The adult and his biological mother both consented.

The problem was article 294 of the Civil Code, which only allows two people to adopt the same adult if they are married to each other. The Milan court sent the question to Rome.

What the court decided on adults

The court declared article 294 unconstitutional “to the extent it does not provide that civil union members may also adopt the same person,” as Money.it summarised the ruling.

Its reasoning is quietly lovely. Adopting an adult, the judges wrote, gives legal recognition to an emotional bond that, because of its quality, intensity and lasting duration, shapes the identity of both the person adopted and the people adopting, Quotidiano Nazionale reported. When everyone involved consents, the court found nothing that could justify denying that recognition, calling the harm “unreasonable and disproportionate.”

Adult adoption might sound niche, but the principle isn’t. The court treated a civil union as a family status in its own right, one that two people can share a single adopted son or daughter through, rather than a lesser version of marriage.

What the court didn’t decide

The second case came from the juvenile court in Venice, which challenged article 29-bis of Italy’s 1983 adoption law. That rule lets only married couples declare themselves available to adopt a child living abroad.

The Constitutional Court declared the questions inadmissible. Weighing how social change affects a child’s best interests, and redesigning the whole system, isn’t its role, it said, according to Quotidiano Nazionale. But it went out of its way to add two things: that “many legal, not only social, changes” have shifted the ground under the old rule, and that Parliament “may well consider” letting same-sex civil-union couples be assessed as adoptive parents for abandoned children, in a spirit of solidarity under Article 2 of the Constitution.

In practice, nothing changes for international adoption until a law does. Stepchild adoption of a partner’s child, which courts have allowed since 2016, still runs through the separate “special cases” route in article 44(d) of the adoption law, Money.it notes.

The reaction

Rights groups welcomed the adult ruling and read the second as a deadline in all but name. Gabriele Piazzoni, secretary general of Arcigay, said the court is once again asking Parliament to use common sense, not ideology, when it comes to parenthood, and that same-sex couples’ family plans keep running into walls. Alessandro Zan, who leads on rights in the Democratic Party’s national secretariat, said the court had made clear that a law on international adoption is not just needed but urgent, according to Quotidiano Nazionale.

The bigger picture

This is the latest in a long line of Italian court rulings filling gaps the legislature hasn’t. In May the same court extended widow pensions to same-sex spouses married abroad before 2016, and we’ve tracked how courts keep expanding parental rights even as Giorgia Meloni’s government pushes a “traditional family” agenda.

It’s also why Italy still sits at 36th of 49 on ILGA-Europe’s Rainbow Map, a ranking we unpacked last week. Judges can widen the door one case at a time. Only Parliament can take it off its hinges.

Photo: Palazzo della Consulta, Rome, by Monticiano via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.